It's a VERY hilarious mental image. I keep busting into laughter every time I try to actually envision it.

Yes. All of it yes. And she totally would. Just make small talk with him. The treats will also escalate from generic chocolate chip cookies to other things as she kind of tries to experiment and learn his preferences. Which ones does he clean the plate for if any?? Tart things, sweet things, bitter things, or savory things?

She'll ask if he's allergic to nuts to be on the safe side.